Blue Blue Cultist sprite 1up-Mushroom's EarthBound Adaption (Fanfic)

sprite 1up-Mushroom

Hello there all you EB fans, with this thread I’ve decided to post my novelization of EarthBound, though it’s more of an adaption really. It makes a few deviations, and a few characters are written differently. With that said, the first chapter!


In the old days, Onett was nothing spectatular. Sure it had a decent arcade, a competent police force and, dare I say it, a Library where kids actually went to read! However one thing was certain, Onett was just an average town, surely nothing exciting would happen there! Well, tell that to the huge Meteor.

It all started in the beautifully specific year of 199x, and the town of Onett was sleeping blissfully. The only one who was actually awake was a guy named Lier X. Aggerate who was an expert sign maker. Other than that, the Onett area was purely peaceful…then the Meteor came. It was all so sudden, it crashed on the peak of a hill, not far from Lier X’s house and it soon gained the attention of the Onett police.

Cars were parked just outside the Meteor area as many officers were either walking around or trying to catch a few Z’s. For once in Onett’s life, there was actually a time when more than 9 policemen were needed. And finally, the Meteor crash shook so bad that it woke Ness up.

Ness, aside from being one of our main characters, was a young ordinary boy no older than 10 years old. When he wasn’t eating a nicely cooked steak, he was in his room sleeping away. When the meteor hit, Ness’ eyes opened immeadiately. He then got out of bed and with a quick change of clothes, sneaked outside his window, eager to see what caused that big boom.

Unfortunately when he arrived at the site, another young boy happened to beat him to the punch. This guy was known as Porky Minch, he wasn’t exactly the nicest person to be around. When he wasn’t stealing ice cream from stores, he was boasting about how tremendously badass he was even though he most likely screamed bloody murder at the sight of a runaway dog.

The fact that he annoyed anyone he talked to really didn’t help. Sure enough, when Ness saw him, Porky was running around the site bugging cops, tipping over signs, and just being a jerk in general. But when Ness entered the site, Porky almost immediately stopped what he was doing and was all over Ness like a fly was all over a garbage heap.

“So…you woke up.” Porky said with an annoyed tone.

“Yeah,” Ness said, “I wanted to see what caused that big boom noise a couple minutes ago.”

“So you thought you could just barge through authorities like you’re some big shot?! Not even considering what the poor, poor officers are feeling?!”

“Isn’t that what you’re doing?”

Porky opened his trap but nothing came out, instead he just scoffed.

“Look, bottom line is, you’re not wanted here Ness. You’ll just get in the way of the good hardworking cops who love my comp-”

Just then a Cop shouted,

“NO WE DON’T! GO AWAY!!!”

Porky coughed awkwardly and said, “They’re…just trying to make you feel special Ness. Look, just go back to your house and I’ll explain it all in the morning. I promise.”

He then held out a pudgy, indicating a handshake. Ness, however just walked back home. Fortunately his Mother hadn’t noticed his absence so all he had to do was sneak in through his window and go back to sleep. While step one was completed flawlessly, step two would fail within mere minutes.

There was a loud and very obnoxious knock at the door. Hoping his mother would get it, Ness tried to go back to sleep, only for his mother to wake him up once more.

“Honey,” she said, “There’s someone here for you.”

But before she said anything else, Ness already knew who she was talking about. And wouldn’t you know it, as soon as he came to the living room, Ness found Porky sitting on a couch.

TLc

Always struggling for balance

  • Halloween Funfest 2013 Overall 3rd
  • ZAWA RRPS Loser
  • Writer's Badge
  • Badge Maker!
  • MOTHER2 Riddles 3+ Wins
  • Writing Bootcamp 2014
  • BFFF Participation
  • M25FF Participation Award
  • Holiday FF 13 Category 1st
  • M25FF Funky Award
  • Summers Art Collab!
  • fanvatar4
  • I believed in Smash
  • !smash collab
  • Lucas Memorial Collab
  • Riddles Lord
  • Veteran's Day Pokemon OU Winner
  • Sonic OC Don't STeal
  • MOTHER3 Riddles Winner X3
  • MOTHER1 Riddles 3 Wins

I hope you don’t mind if I review this.


I found your writing to be decent. You worked well with keeping to EarthBound’s story. The descriptions were just the right length. You didn’t bore me with details, but you didn’t make the environment feel flat by not giving me many details. I found it odd to have Ness talk, but then again, the silent protagonist concept wouldn’t work so well in writing so this was a good move on your part. I liked how Ness didn’t get caught by his mom when sneaking out. In the game it is possible to go outside in your pajamas but on the way back you have to talk to Ness’s mom. I think that you should have details like this more often as it makes the story much more interesting. I’m not sure how far you will go in the next chapter but when you get to the part where Porky and Picky get punished, don’t think that you have to stick with them getting spanked 10,000 times like in the Japanese version or them not being able to have desert for the rest of the decade like in the American version. This is your chance to be creative.

The only real problem is that I can’t imagine you writing the whole of EarthBound’s story. I can imagine you making it to about Twoson, but after that you may just get bored of this concept. You might need to make a gimmick to keep you, and others interested in this fanfic. Maybe have Jeff kidnapped instead of Paula in Fourside. Or maybe have the characters comment on the food they purchased. I haven’t posted any fanfic’s on the writing forum yet (although I plan to) so I wouldn’t recommend using the examples I just gave.

It’s just important to remember to keep your writing from becoming bland and uninteresting. You need a hook to grab the readers attention. This “hook” should be as early in the chapter as possible in order to keep otherwise uninterested people interested. The closest thing I could find to a hook was where you mentioned the Library. This is more of minor detail than a hook so just keep that in mind. It’s also important to have something exciting happen in the ending as that will leave the reader yearning for more. Cutting off the chapter with Porky sitting on a coach was decent in terms of timing, but this would only be effective to leave the reader wanting for more if they haven’t played EarthBound. Since this is a Mother forum, most people are aware of what happens in EarthBound. This returns to my point earlier of having something different from the game happen. Maybe Picky appeared instead of Porky.

Here we go, count zero!
Itoi Shigesato’s No. 1 Birthday Party

sprite 1up-Mushroom

Now, on to Chapter 2!


To say that Porky was panicking was a huge understatement. He was going nuts, shifting his eyes nervously, panting heavily, and worst of all, getting his sweat all over the new couch. Ness felt nervous, why did Porky need him this late at night? Couldn’t he get someone else to do this favor for him?

When Porky saw Ness he was ecstatic, he immediately landed near Ness’ feet and groveled.

“Oh Ness,” Porky cried acting completely melodramatic, “I’m in deep trouble! Will you please help me?! PLEASE!”

Ness looked at his Mother who’s name was Linda, begging her to kick him out but Linda, being the kind soul she was just patted Porky on the shoulder and said:

“What’s wrong Dear?”

Porky stopped groveling and looked at Linda.

“Well, you see me and my brother Picky were outside looking at the Meteor site when…sob…Picky vanished!”

Ness quickly chimed in, “You mean you lost him-”

“VANISHED! One moment he was just laying besides a tree, the next moment he’s GONE! I NEED YOUR HELP NESS, PLEASE!”

With a quick look at her face, Ness knew his mother wanted to talk so they quietly went to the kitchen.

“Ness, can you please help him find his brother?”

“No, let him find his brother on his own.”

“Ness!”

“Look, I’m tired of him crawling to either us or someone else for help because of his stupid actions!”

“But Ness, that isn’t the nice thing to do.”

“Probably because the nice thing never worked-”

Linda stopped playing nice and grabbed his hand.

“Listen here, young man! I’m not going to have you selfishly kicking someone aside when they need your help!”

One sigh later, Ness finally nodded in agreement and got a hug in return.

“Thank you,” she said, “I’ll make it up to you in the morning.”

Ness then walked to Porky and quite reluctantly said, “Alright, I’ll help you find Picky.”

Porky’s eyes widened, “REALLY?! Oh thank you Ness!”

He then sat on the couch whiled yawning. “I’m just gonna sit here and-”

“Oh no!” Ness said, “You’re coming with me!”

“What?” Porky said as if that phrase offended himdeeply. “Why? I’m not that useful!”

Ness then got sarcastic, “What? Oh, you joker! You’re the most useful person EVER! In fact, since you’re so observant maybe you can help me find out where Picky last was! I mean I could get lost of confused without your amazing guidance!”

“But-”

Ness dropped the scarcasm and flat out said, “Look, you either help me find your brother or you find him on your own, that’s my final offer.”

Porky turned to Linda in an attempt to get out of this but even she shrugged as if saying ‘Sorry, Ness has a point’. With no other option, Porky grumbled as he said, “Let’s go.”

Ness couldn’t agree more as he got his favorite cracked bat which was useful for defense against muggers and such.

Before they left however, Porky confrotned Linda again.

“May I at least have one of your Lemon flavored popsicles?”

“Sure, they’re in the fridge.”

Porky just opened the fridge inside and grabbed one without even shutting the door.

“Alright,” he said throwing the wrapper on the floor, “Let’s blow this popsicle stand.”

Right before they left, Linda asked “Can you at least pick up the wrapper?”

Followed by Porky saying “Can you at least pick up the wrapper?” in a mocking tone.

Now, both Ness and Porky were outside, ready to find Picky and get this whole mess over with!

Hopefully this chapter is a bit longer. Also, as you might notice, Ness isn’t exactly the pitch perfect boy he was in the games. For those of you who are worried, no I’m not making Ness a complete and utter jerk though it may seem like that. I just wanted to make him a character that’s not only interesting to read but also to write.

If he just followed everyone’s orders without even questioning anything once well he’d just be a chore to read and write about.

Well that’s all I have to say for now, be sure to give constructive criticism if you decide to review. Merely saying “DIS IS KOOL!” will not do it for me.

TLc

Always struggling for balance

  • Halloween Funfest 2013 Overall 3rd
  • ZAWA RRPS Loser
  • Writer's Badge
  • Badge Maker!
  • MOTHER2 Riddles 3+ Wins
  • Writing Bootcamp 2014
  • BFFF Participation
  • M25FF Participation Award
  • Holiday FF 13 Category 1st
  • M25FF Funky Award
  • Summers Art Collab!
  • fanvatar4
  • I believed in Smash
  • !smash collab
  • Lucas Memorial Collab
  • Riddles Lord
  • Veteran's Day Pokemon OU Winner
  • Sonic OC Don't STeal
  • MOTHER3 Riddles Winner X3
  • MOTHER1 Riddles 3 Wins

I feel obliged to give my thoughts on this part as well.


I’m glad that this part was filled with dialogue. I find that it gives nice character development. The last line Porky said really had a lasting impression. You clearly wanted to depict Ness as an ordinary kid. This is what Itoi wanted so it’s good that you have kept with the Mother spirit. Ness’s argument with his Mom tended to drag out like a typical parent-child argument. This is a good to help depict Ness as an ordinary child but I felt like it dragged out for too long. When writing dialogue you want to try to cut out unnecessary chit-chat. Maybe you could have reduced it to they argued for a long time until finally Ness said… Since you have separated your story into chapters you don’t need to worry about one chapter being too short. I would rather have something short and effective over something long and full of unnecessary details.

Here is the point which interests me most. You gave Ness’s mom a name, Linda. This has it’s pro’s and con’s. You don’t have to write Ness’s mom said this or Ness’s mom said that each time you make her speak. It also makes her seem more like an individual person rather than someone who is their for the purpose of helping Ness. It’s also much more forgivable than giving Ness’s family a last name. As for the cons… to me it was really awkward to read something where Ness’s mom has a name. Maybe it’s because I’m an EarthBound fan and I already feel like Ness’s mom has been established as Ness’s mom and not by any other name. This is really a nitpick so you can ignore this if you want to. I would recommend to try to use pronouns as much as you can whenever Ness’s mom speaks as it’s so awkward for Ness’s mom to be referred to as Linda.

That’s all I have to say for now. It was still a nice read so keep it going. Just remember to cut down on the excess dialogue and try your best to refer to Ness’s mom using pronouns whenever you can. Keep developing your characters like you are already doing.

Here we go, count zero!
Itoi Shigesato’s No. 1 Birthday Party

sprite 1up-Mushroom

Here we go, the next chapter in EarthBound!


The trip up to the meteor site was less bearable than last time. The main reason was because Porky kept screaming at every Spiteful Crow and Runaway Dog they encountered. At first, Ness found it very amusing, but after the 500th time this happened, it was really getting on his nerves.

He finally snapped when Porky screamed at a rowdy mouse that Ness slapped him in the face and yelled, “GROW UP!!!”

“Well it’s YOUR fault I’m out here!” Porky said,

“You already WERE out here, in fact if you paid attention to your brother for once none of this would’ve happened!”

Fortunately Porky couldn’t think of a clever comeback and remained quiet throughout the remainder of the trip. Sadly for Ness, his anger would only rise when they finally reached the site. As soon as they started looked for Picky…who was sleeping under the same tree except on the other side now.

Porky knew he was in danger when he saw Ness’ eyes twitch.

“You’re telling me…he never left the site?” Ness said desperately trying to keep his cool. “That all you had to do was look behind the same tree and all would have been well?”

Porky stammered with his sentences, “W-w-w-well umm, umm, thanks for uh, helping-helping me out best buddy!”

Just then, Picky suddenly awoke, needless to say waking up to find your neighbour about to beat your brother with a cracked bat is rather odd.

“Umm, does anyone want to fill me in on what’s happening?”

Ness reluctantly stopped before the beatdown began and explained the situation. It was shocking to see how understanding Picky was.

“Yeah, he often does that to people, sorry for making you have to deal with him man.”

“It’s alright,” Ness said, “Let’s just-”

Just then the meteor began shining.

“Oh no,” Porky said, “Oh no, the meteors gonna get us, WE’RE GONNA-”

“SHUT UP PORKY!” Shouted Picky and Ness, as the meteor began shining a strange buzzing noise also emerged from the meteor.

Then, when it seemed this couldn’t get any stranger a small flying insect came from the meteor.

“Hello there, earthlings.” The insect said,

“Did that thing just talk to us?” Picky said,

“My name is Buzz Buzz and I have come from the future to guide someone, that person is you Ness.”

At first no one knew what to say until Picky broke the ice.

“Whoa, you came in a Time Traveling Meteor?”

“Listen,” Buzz Buzz said, “We don’t have much time, I’m not the only one…HIDE!”

Just then another blast came out of nowhere and after it died down, a huge silver cyborg was in its place.

“Well, well, well,” the Cyborg said, “We meet again Buzz Buzz.”

TLc

Always struggling for balance

  • Halloween Funfest 2013 Overall 3rd
  • ZAWA RRPS Loser
  • Writer's Badge
  • Badge Maker!
  • MOTHER2 Riddles 3+ Wins
  • Writing Bootcamp 2014
  • BFFF Participation
  • M25FF Participation Award
  • Holiday FF 13 Category 1st
  • M25FF Funky Award
  • Summers Art Collab!
  • fanvatar4
  • I believed in Smash
  • !smash collab
  • Lucas Memorial Collab
  • Riddles Lord
  • Veteran's Day Pokemon OU Winner
  • Sonic OC Don't STeal
  • MOTHER3 Riddles Winner X3
  • MOTHER1 Riddles 3 Wins

Line 2 had some grammatical errors. You need to make sure that you write the names of the enemies in plural forms, not singular forms. Also, you have a typo in the line, “Porky knew he was he in danger when he saw Ness’ eye twitch”. These only bug me because it’s a flaw on such a good piece of writing.

I think that these chapters keep on getting better and better. This was easily the most entertaining chapter so far. I really like how you handled this scene, since in the game, it’s nothing more than walking to the meteorite. I knew you were going to mention Porky’s cowardice in battle but you handled that really well. It was short and to the point. You could have gone on about what sort of stunts he pulled but you didn’t. I notice that you didn’t have King tag along. Many first time players will take King along so this was a good choice on your part to make it seem different from many peoples first time playthroughs. I usually don’t take King along so I didn’t even notice that you hadn’t included King until writing this review.

I like your choice in having the Starman Jr. appear immediately after Buzz buzz exits the meteor. It just cuts out unnecessary text saying that Ness and co. walked down the hill. I really liked the banter between Porky, Ness, and Picky. It was light and humorous, just like how EarthBound is supposed to be. By the end of the chapter you left me wanting more. This is a good thing as this makes me anxious to see the next chapter. Some might say that this means that the chapter is too short, but I think it just means you ended the chapter on a good part.

I didn’t post much criticism in this review but that was because there weren’t many flaws for me to criticize.

Here we go, count zero!
Itoi Shigesato’s No. 1 Birthday Party

sprite 1up-Mushroom

Now for Chapter 4!


“What…What is that?” Ness asked in a terrified tone.

“A Starman Junior,” Buzz Buzz said.

The Starman Junior was huge, with a weird black symbol on its chest. It talked some more,

“You know Buzz Buzz,” it said, “You’ve really caused us some problems. I’m afraid, in order to stop this whole mess, I’m gonna have to kill you.”

“Do your worst,” Buzz Buzz said,

“NO!” Porky shouted, “DON’T LISTEN TO THAT THING, PLEASE! LET US GO! PLEASE! I’LL DO ANYTHING!!!”

Picky scoffed, “You know sometimes I wonder who’s the real big brother in this family-”

“SILENCE!” The Starman Junior commanded, it then pointed at Buzz Buzz.

“I outta just fry you now Buzz Buzz but since I’m such a nice guy, I’ll let you deliver the first move.”

Ness however wasn’t going to take this, “Look, we’re not afraid of you!”

Picky joined in, “Yeah! We can take you on easily!”

The Starman was about to reply when suddenly police sirens filled the sky. They all looked down to see piles and piles of cop cars driving up the mountain. The Starman Junior laughed and pointed at the cop cars.

“PSI FIRE BETA!” It yelled.

It was a scary sight, for fire had come out of nowhere and absolutely demolished all the cars to a burning crisp! Trees were catching fire, many crows and dogs couldn’t escape, and worst of all, Ness swore he saw his mother at the porch of his house, trying to find her son amongst the chaos. The Starman Junior then looked at the boys.

“So, you still want to take me on?” It said.

Buzz Buzz then chanted, “PSI SHIELD SIGMA!”

Just then, an entire psychic shield absorbed him and the boys.

“Now, we’re talking!” The Starman Junior said, “PSI FIRE BETA!”

An entire wave of fire came sprawling at them, fortunately the shield vaporized it the instant they touched. Buzz Buzz then chanted, “PSI FIRE BETA!”

The Starman Junior couldn’t dodge the attack. Buzz Buzz chanted it again, and again! However, as he chanted the move one more time, the Starman Junior chanted PSI ALPHA which dealt enough damage to the shield to make it wore off. The huge power of the move had severely damaged the boys but fortunately since it only partly affected them, it just knocked them out cold and added some burn marks to their body, it was a miracle that they had even survived.

When Ness awoke, he found himself in his room. By his side was his mother, his sister, and Buzz Buzz.

“That…” Ness said, “That was some battle, wasn’t it?”

So as you can tell, the battle was a lot more intense than in the game. Also, instead of just mindlessly beating the Starman Junior, Ness, Picky, and Porky actually got hurt. We’ll hear more about their fate later in chapter 5. As always, please give constructive criticism if you want to review.

TLc

Always struggling for balance

  • Halloween Funfest 2013 Overall 3rd
  • ZAWA RRPS Loser
  • Writer's Badge
  • Badge Maker!
  • MOTHER2 Riddles 3+ Wins
  • Writing Bootcamp 2014
  • BFFF Participation
  • M25FF Participation Award
  • Holiday FF 13 Category 1st
  • M25FF Funky Award
  • Summers Art Collab!
  • fanvatar4
  • I believed in Smash
  • !smash collab
  • Lucas Memorial Collab
  • Riddles Lord
  • Veteran's Day Pokemon OU Winner
  • Sonic OC Don't STeal
  • MOTHER3 Riddles Winner X3
  • MOTHER1 Riddles 3 Wins

This part really reminded me of Harry Potter. The ending reminded of of how in the end of the first book Harry didn’t defeat Voldemort and fainted. When he woke up he found himself in the hospital. I’m not too sure if it’s a good thing or a bad thing. It’s good that it’s different from the games, but I’m not sure if it’s a good thing if it reminds me of something else too much. Granted, this could be a huge coincidence as you might be playing on the fact that if you lose a battle during the beginning of the game, you end up at home.

I think that the PK Fire Beta needs to be more consistent. I’m sure that you yourself are aware of this so here’s what I suggest:

  • Tone down the damage it does to the police cars.
  • Or, make Ness be in more pain from the PK Fire Beta attack. The fact that he can still talk makes the PK Fire Beta attack seem underwhelming when it was used on Ness.
  • Or, make the Starman Jr. use PK Fire Alpha instead of Beta on Ness.
  • Or, make the PK Fire Beta destroy Buzz buzz’s damaged shield. Since the shield was damaged it was enough to only slightly block the attack.

I noticed that you decided to have the characters chant their PSI. I know that Ness and Lucas do that in Smash Brothers but it don’t think that you have to make PSI like a magic spell. I really can’t assess this choice since it is neither a good point, nor a bad point. It’s just something for you to decide on as I’m okay either way.

I think that it was a good choice to have the Starman Jr. attack others before Ness. It really builds up tension as Ness and co. are going to fight a ridiculously strong enemy. Porky’s cowardice was a good way of emphasizing Ness and Picky’s bravery. If you hadn’t mentioned Porky’s cowardice then I probably wouldn’t have even gotten the feeling that Ness and Picky were being brave. Having Ness lose was also a good choice, and one that I’m sure that you are aware of. It emphasizes the fact that the enemies Ness will face in the future are no pushover. In the games, the Starman Jr. was rather underwhelming since it’s impossible to lose to it.

One final thing I noticed was that throughout the story you mentioned Ness’s mom from Ness’s point of view. What I mean by this is that you said stuff like “Ness saw his mother” instead of “Linda was there”. I didn’t even notice this until writing the review so that means you are doing a good job of making it sound natural.

Here we go, count zero!
Itoi Shigesato’s No. 1 Birthday Party

sprite 1up-Mushroom

Let’s dive into Chapter 5! Also, beware the punny title, it was downright irresistible.


As Ness finally spoke, everyone was shocked and overjoyed. From the “Thank The Lord” quote from his mother to the “Yay! You’re alive!” quote from his sister, everyone was happy to see Ness awake. Ness however turned to Buzz Buzz and asked:

“How did we survive?”

“Heh, it seems you’re not one to waste time,” Buzz Buzz said, “After you all fainted due to the sheer power of the PSI, I fortunately was able to distract the Starman Junior away from us and this town by pretending we were all dead. The Starman Junior fell for it and transported back to wherever it came from.”

“So,” Ness said with a slight tone of disappointment, “You didn’t kill it?”

“Sadly no, it’s still out there, alive.”

Ness went silent, wondering if he would ever meet that Starman Junior again. Then another question popped in his mind,

“But, how did I end up here?”

“Well, you should thank your mother Linda for that.” Buzz Buzz said, “She was able to call the fire department and within seconds, the fire was gone and you and the other kids were taken home.”

“Oh, thanks mom.” Ness said with a smile, to which his mother smiled back in response. Ness then remembered something important.

“Hey, uh Tracy?”

His little sister looked at him.

“Can you check on my dog, please? I wonder how’s he feeling.”

Once Tracy left Ness then looked at Buzz Buzz.

“So, why did you come for me?”

Buzz Buzz sighed, “You see Ness, I need you to collect 8 melodies for me.”

Ness was confused, “Why?”

But before Buzz Buzz could say another word, Ness’ mother intervened.

“Actually, Ness honey,” she said trying too hard to sound cheery, “I just remembered something I have to tell your little friend, so um, if you’ll excuse us.”

With that they both left his room though they only went out to the hall so Ness could still hear them.

“He has to know, Linda.” Buzz Buzz said, “The fa-”

“Don’t say it so loud!” She hissed, “He might hear us!”

“Look, I realize this knowledge might be heavy for him to understand but he has to know.”

A sigh was heard.

“Can you just hold it off now?”

“If not now, then when? When he’s practically completed his quest? That would be a fine time to tell him what’s really going on!”

Silence was in the air until Buzz Buzz broke it.

“I don’t agree with you, but if it’s what you want, then I won’t tell him why he has to do this.”

“Thank you.”

With that, they both re-entered the room.

“Well, Ness? How are you feeling?” Buzz Buzz asked.

“Pretty good, I guess.”

“Can you walk and fight?”

Ness was about to say no but then looked in amazement as he saw all of his wounds and scars were gone.

“Uh, yeah, I actually am.” He said while flexing his hands.

“Alright then, to begin our quest we have to go Giant’s step. That’s where the first melody is.”

Ness nodded as he put on some clothes that were in good condition and grabbed his bat.

“Let’s go.”

With a hug and a few goodbyes, Buzz Buzz and Ness were off to Giant’s step. As they began walking however, they found Picky standing by a tree and holding a rather nice looking baseball bat. As he spotted them, Picky smiled and handed Ness the bat.

“For you,” he said, “It’s in better condition than the one you have.”

As Ness grabbed the bat he then said, “Thanks, man.”

“I’d go with you wherever you’re going” Picky said, “But my parents wouldn’t let me, besides I wouldn’t be very useful.”

Ness smiled, “Trust me, you already proved you are. Take care.”

As Ness headed f0r town, he heard Picky say the same thing. Now, things were about to begin.

Oh boy, have things changed from the games this time! I hope you enjoyed this game and remember to leave some constructive criticism if you review.

TLc

Always struggling for balance

  • Halloween Funfest 2013 Overall 3rd
  • ZAWA RRPS Loser
  • Writer's Badge
  • Badge Maker!
  • MOTHER2 Riddles 3+ Wins
  • Writing Bootcamp 2014
  • BFFF Participation
  • M25FF Participation Award
  • Holiday FF 13 Category 1st
  • M25FF Funky Award
  • Summers Art Collab!
  • fanvatar4
  • I believed in Smash
  • !smash collab
  • Lucas Memorial Collab
  • Riddles Lord
  • Veteran's Day Pokemon OU Winner
  • Sonic OC Don't STeal
  • MOTHER3 Riddles Winner X3
  • MOTHER1 Riddles 3 Wins

Sorry I couldn’t review this earlier. I was sleeping.


Once again you show your expertise in dialogue writing. This is clearly your strongest point. None of the dialogue felt flat or monotone. You seem to be creating lots of personality for Ness, Picky and Ness’s mom. It’s nice that you focus on building up Picky because he got so little attention in the games. It’s also interesting how Picky doesn’t hold any grudges against Ness. I know that that was the case in the games, but it’s emphasized a little more here so that’s good. It was also a nice twist from the games. I wander what will happen to Buzz buzz now, how will he meet his doom?

There were some minor story elements which slightly bugged me. Your writing was fine of course. Firstly, Tracy is just sent to check on King, but never returns until presumably the goodbye scene. To me, it seemed like you were writing her out of the picture. To be honest, I don’t know if I could find a way to write her back into the picture without it seeming forced. It’s just a minor little nitpick so don’t get too bothered by it. Another minor thing was how when Ness and Picky see each other, they don’t ask each other if they are alright. If they were attacked by a fire wielding space alien, I think the first thing they would do would be to ask if they are alright. You handled that scene really well though so adding in some extra lines may taint the otherwise good scene.

So overall I think that this chapter was handled very well. It has a nice flow to it so that is why I was hesitant to criticize some parts as you may break the flow should you decide to edit it. Apart from some really minor nitpicks I really couldn’t find any problems with the story.

Here we go, count zero!
Itoi Shigesato’s No. 1 Birthday Party

sprite 1up-Mushroom

Well, here’s chapter 6!


“Now, I’m sure you know where Giants Step is, correct?” Buzz Buzz asked.

“Sure I do.” Ness answered, “It’s hard to get to though.”

Buzz Buzz looked puzzled.

“Well you see, the pathway to it is locked and the only way to get it unlocked is by visiting the mayor.”

“Mayor, you say? Well, let’s go find the mayor then!”

Ness groaned, “Oh man I forgot, we have to talk to the Mayor!”

As they continued on with conversation about how Mayor B.H. Pirkle was the most incompetent mayor to ever curse Onett, an odd group of punks blocked their way. They all wore these black suits with masks that looked like shark heads.

“What the?” Ness exclaimed, “Get out of our way!”

“Not yet!” The one in the middle said, “In order to get to downtown Onett, you have to pay the price!”

“Which is?” Buzz Buzz asked,

“50 bucks.”

“No way!” Ness said, “We’re not paying that!”

“Oh yeah?” The leader said, “And just how are you gonna-”

SMAAAASH!

With a quick swing of his bat, Ness was able to beat the leader and distract the others as they escaped.

“Who where those men?” Buzz Buzz asked, panting.

“Those…Those guys were the sharks.” Ness panted, “A gang that just recently formed together.”

As they settled down, Ness and Buzz Buzz quickly headed to the Town Hall in order to meet the Mayor. Besides the usual bored secretaries and complaining hippies, Ness also found these weird sycophantic minions who kept claiming how the Mayor was great and all that. However, as they entered Mayor Pirkle’s office, they weren’t convinced.

The Mayor was sitting at his desk smoking a cigar, and rejecting any calls. It was only when Ness said “Hello” that alerted the Mayor that he had company.

“What do you want?!” The Mayor said impatiently, trying to suck all the good stuff out of his cigar before digging into another one.

“Well, we were you told you had access to a key which would unlock the path to Giants Step.” Buzz Buzz said,

The Mayor just grunted, “No way am I gonna give you bozos the key. Too risky, you could get lost in that place, and then you wouldn’t be able to vote for my re-election!”

Ness shot a look at Buzz Buzz that just screamed ‘Can you BELIEVE this guy?!’ and then looked at the Mayor again.

“Listen,” Ness said, “It’s really important we get there, we’ll do anything to get it.”

The Mayor’s eyes widened, “Anything?”

Ness mentally kicked himself for not being specific.

“Well, now that you put it that way, there IS something I could have you do.” The Mayor said, “Beat the Sharks.”

“What?!” Ness shouted.

“Yeah, kick their butts, make ‘em wet their pants! Listen kid, the people at Onett are scared out of their minds! They can’t think about anything else! So if you beat them up, teach ’em a lesson AND let me take credit for it-”

“ARE YOU SERIOUS?!”

“Then I’ll give you the key. Deal?”

Ness had enough of this and was about to leave but Buzz Buzz said, “Deal.”

Ness was shocked as they left the town hall.

“Why would you do that?!”

“Because,” Buzz Buzz said, “We need to get to Giant’s Step as soon as possible. Besides, it’ll do you good to fight these men. It’ll make you stronger.”

Ness sighed, “I just hope we won’t get mauled to death.”

“Trust me Ness, these guys will be Child’s play compared to the dangers we’ll face later on. You need to pratice your fighting skills. Now come on, let’s teach those punks a lesson.”

Remember to leave constructive criticism when you review!

TLc

Always struggling for balance

  • Halloween Funfest 2013 Overall 3rd
  • ZAWA RRPS Loser
  • Writer's Badge
  • Badge Maker!
  • MOTHER2 Riddles 3+ Wins
  • Writing Bootcamp 2014
  • BFFF Participation
  • M25FF Participation Award
  • Holiday FF 13 Category 1st
  • M25FF Funky Award
  • Summers Art Collab!
  • fanvatar4
  • I believed in Smash
  • !smash collab
  • Lucas Memorial Collab
  • Riddles Lord
  • Veteran's Day Pokemon OU Winner
  • Sonic OC Don't STeal
  • MOTHER3 Riddles Winner X3
  • MOTHER1 Riddles 3 Wins

I noticed one error in this. It’s “B.H. Pirkle”, not “B.S. Pirkle”. I always remember it as Bald Head Pirkle. Also, I wander how Buzz Buzz can look puzzled? You don’t need to change that part but I do wander how it’s possible.

I like how you handled Buzz Buzz. I was wandering what you were going to do with him since you let him live. He is a way to have dialogue going on when Ness is travelling solo.This way you don’t have to have Ness talk to himself until Paula comes along. You made a good use of the character.

I also felt like the mayor as a character was built up well. In the games we don’t interact with him much. After beating up the sharks he gives you the key and takes credit. I wander how you are going to handle the scene where Ness reads the newspaper to find out that the media knows that Ness was the one who beat up the Sharks and not B.H. Pirkle. I also like how this scene didn’t just feel like something which was meant to transition Ness leaving home to Ness getting to the Sharks. It felt like it actually had some point to it. In the games, B.H. Pirkle doesn’t ask Ness to beat up the sharks. You didn’t need to add that event, but by doing so, you added a whole new dimension to B.H. Pirkle. You even managed to make me dislike the character a bit. That is a sign of good writing.

Here we go, count zero!
Itoi Shigesato’s No. 1 Birthday Party

sprite 1up-Mushroom

Sorry I haven’t posted in a while. I’ve been working on another project with a user. That and I’ve been trying to watch some movies I haven’t watched yet.


Well this day sure had a rocky start for Ness and Buzz Buzz. Not only did they have to put up with the Mayor’s bullcrap, but they also had to take down an entire gang in order to get to Giant’s Step. Fortunately Ness was smart enough to know one thing about the Shark’s. If their leader backs down, so do they, that way neither Ness or Buzz Buzz would have to get hurt. And luckily for Ness, he knew where this leader was.

The Onett Arcade was infamous for many reasons. For one thing the arcade only had a total of 3 games that weren’t copies. There’s also the fact that it’s owner Frankie snapped and started a gang called the Sharks but that’s a given. As Ness and Buzz Buzz approached the door to the arcade, three shark’s blocked the path.

“What do you want?!” The shark in the middle demanded.

“We need to see your leader.” Buzz Buzz said rather coldly.

“Sorry guys,” the shark in the middle said, “He’s not accepting visits.”

Buzz Buzz then said, “You have one chance to save yourselfs.”

All three sharks pulled out pocket knifes.

“That a challenge bug brain?!”

Buzz Buzz just said, “No, no, challenge implies that you guys have a chance.”

When the Sharks didn’t move, Buzz Buzz chanted “PSI ROCKIN ALPHA!”

A huge mix of colors lunged at the sharks and knocked them out cold. Just then another shark came out the door.

“What’s with all the-” the shakr began until he saw all three sharks out cold on the street with Ness and Buzz Buzz standing over them.

“So uh, can we see your leader?” Ness asked with a little smirk on his face.

The shark however put up his fists, “OVER MY DEAD BOD-”

SMAAAAAAASH!

With a swing of a bat the foolish shark joined his friends on the ground. Once Ness and Buzz Buzz entered the arcade the first thing they saw was a man about 29 or 32 playing a game of Donkey Kong while sipping a cup of coffee.

“I heard that you’re looking for me kid.” The man said, his eyes never left the screen.

Ness tensed up while holding his bat firmly. Buzz Buzz was still able to speak, “Sir, we need you to disband your Shark gang at once.”

Frankie’s eyes left the screen and focused on Buzz Buzz, Ness couldn’t notice of ocurse since they were blocked by Frankie’s sunglasses. With a sip of his coffee, Frankie laughed a bit and leaned against the arcade machine.

“And uh, why should I disband the Sharks? They aren’t causing a lot of damage.”

Ness got angry, “Are you serious?! They’re acting like total mainiacs! Some people are afraid to leave their homes because of these guys! Just this morning a few of them were demanding we pay a fee for walking to Onett!”

Frankie drank the remainder of his coffee and threw the cup on the floor.

“And if I say no?”

Ness raised his bat while Buzz Buzz said, “I think you know the answer to that.”

Frankie folded his arms and smirked.

“Interesting. Tell you what boys, let me make a compromise. If you can beat me up real good I’ll tell the Shark’s to beat it. What do you say?”

Frankie pulled out two big daggers.

“Deal?”

Ness and Buzz Buzz looked at each other. Ness then firmly gripped his bat even more as he said, “You’re on.”

TLc

Always struggling for balance

  • Halloween Funfest 2013 Overall 3rd
  • ZAWA RRPS Loser
  • Writer's Badge
  • Badge Maker!
  • MOTHER2 Riddles 3+ Wins
  • Writing Bootcamp 2014
  • BFFF Participation
  • M25FF Participation Award
  • Holiday FF 13 Category 1st
  • M25FF Funky Award
  • Summers Art Collab!
  • fanvatar4
  • I believed in Smash
  • !smash collab
  • Lucas Memorial Collab
  • Riddles Lord
  • Veteran's Day Pokemon OU Winner
  • Sonic OC Don't STeal
  • MOTHER3 Riddles Winner X3
  • MOTHER1 Riddles 3 Wins

A few interesting choices here. Firstly, Buzz Buzz’s use of PSI Rockin. I’m not sure if this is true, but I think that this may be foreshadowing of the future. Ness can’t use PSI yet right? Maybe Buzz Buzz teaches Ness his PSI. Don’t tell me if it was meant to be foreshadowing or not. I want it to be a surprise. Foreshadowing or not, it makes Buzz Buzz feel much closer to Ness as PSI Rockin is supposed to be Ness’ signature move. It also makes me wander how you are going to deal with the fact that Giygas can use PSI Rockin while under the influence of the devil’s machine. EarthBound didn’t explain PSI Rockin well enough to me so I hope that you can provide a decent substitute to the significance of PSI Rockin.

Another interesting choice is calling Frank as Frankie. Currently Frank is supposed to be the big baddie. Later on he is a friend to Ness who even helps him defeat Giygas. Calling him Frankie helps him seem more friendly as it seems like a pet name. Calling him Frankie instead of Frank in this chapter seems to downplay the intimidation he could have had. It would be strange to call him Frank in one chapter and then Frankie in the next chapter so keep it as Frankie if you want to. If you were to switch between Frank and Frankie then I suggest that after he is defeated, Frank asks to be called Frankie instead Frank. Not really a big deal, but still an interesting choice on your part.

The last thing I would like to talk about, is how Buzz Buzz seems to have the lead role and not Ness. This is a perfectly fine choice as you want to depict Ness as an ordinary kid. Admittedly, in the games, it was rather far-fetched at Ness could beat up the Sharks. It was a video game so it didn’t matter much. I’m glad that you’ve gone through the more realistic route of having Buzz Buzz doing most of the damage to the Sharks. I assume that Buzz Buzz is going to die at around the time Paula is introduced, so I think it will show some nice character development for Ness. Here in the beginning, he would be lost without Buzz Buzz. Later on, he will have enough responsibility to guide a party of four. This is one of the themes that Itoi wanted to show in his games, so I hope you continue to show Ness’s growth.

Here we go, count zero!
Itoi Shigesato’s No. 1 Birthday Party

sprite 1up-Mushroom

Wow, it’s been a LOONG time since I last updated huh? Well, let’s continue with chapter 8!


As soon as the challenge was accepted Frankie lunged at Ness with his pocket knife. However, a quick cahnt of “PSI ROCKING BETA” prevented him from doing any damage. Frankie crash landed at a nearby pinball machine headfirst. Ness saw his chance and charged at Frankie with his bat, hoping to smash a resignation out of him.

Unfortunately Frankie had other plans. As Ness was about to land a smash, Frankie quickly swung his pocket knife across Ness’ stomach, resulting in a nicely shaped cut. As Ness grabbed his stomach in agony, Frankie shakingly stood up and wiped some blood that drooled from his lips.

A chuckled emerged from his crookedly rotten teeth, “You haven’t been in too many fights have you?”

Ness groaned in response as Frankie shoved him into an arcade cabinet. Just then Buzz Buzz started to chant “PSI-” until Frankie clocked him with a cup. Buzz Buzz fell to the floor, unconscious. Ness almost screamed in shock, but couldn’t.

“Ha ha ha ha ha,” Frankie laughed, “Looks like you can’t rely on your bug crutch anymore, kid! Give up?”

Ness just frowned and said, “No.”

With that, Frankie struck Ness’ arm. Ness yelled in pain, dropping his bat and grabbing his arm in an attempt to stop it from hurting.

“I’m getting sick of punks like you who think they can just easily beat up anyone they want! Give up now while you can!”

Ness looked everywhere, hoping for some kind of way to get him down. Suddenly, Ness saw that his bat was exactly near Frankie’s left foot. Cautiously Ness said, “Fine, you win.”

Frankie smirked, “I knew you couldn’t do it kid. Be glad you’re still-”

Just then Ness grabbed his bat and with a quick hit Frankie’s ankle suddenly hurt like hell.

“OW, SON OF A-” Frankie shouted as he fell down, only moaning for the next minute. As he finally looked at Ness-

SMAAAASH!

And Frankie crashed into a Donkey Kong Arcade cabinet. Ness then approached Frankie with extreme caution. As Frankie slowly stood up, a smile emerged from his face. Frankie then clapped his hands at Ness, his face seemed much more warm and friendly.

After a little laugh Frankie then said, “What do you know? Looks like you do have a fight in you kid. I think you’d make a great member of the Sharks-”

Ness groaned, fearing this was all for not.

“But then, I wouldn’t be honoring our agreement would I?” Frankie added.

Ness smiled in relief as a dazed Buzz Buzz flew to Ness.

“Ugh,” Buzz Buzz moaned, “What…What happened?”

Frankie pulled out a piece of paper and scribbled something on it while explaining to Buzz Buzz the situation.

“Really?” Buzz Buzz said, surprised at Ness’ strength. “I’m impressed.”

Frankie then gave the note to Ness.

“Take that to Pirkle,” he instructed, “He’ll be convinced.”

Ness looked confused, “How do you know-”

“Pirkle sent you?” Frankie scoffed, “You’re not the first guy that idiot sent here to teach us a lesson. Well, kid-”

“It’s Ness actually.”

Frankie smiled, “Well Ness, good luck on your journey. I hope you win out in the end.”

Frankie then raised out his hand, a hand which Ness gladly shook. Before they went, Frankie stopped them and gave Ness a bag full of cheeseburgers.

“Consider them a gift.” Frankie said.

Ness just nodded his head and then left the Arcade with Buzz Buzz.

“You know,” Ness said, “Frankie’s actually not that bad of a guy once you’re on his good side.”

“Let’s just head for the Town Hall next.” Buzz Buzz said, “The sooner we get to Giant’s Step the better.”

TLc

Always struggling for balance

  • Halloween Funfest 2013 Overall 3rd
  • ZAWA RRPS Loser
  • Writer's Badge
  • Badge Maker!
  • MOTHER2 Riddles 3+ Wins
  • Writing Bootcamp 2014
  • BFFF Participation
  • M25FF Participation Award
  • Holiday FF 13 Category 1st
  • M25FF Funky Award
  • Summers Art Collab!
  • fanvatar4
  • I believed in Smash
  • !smash collab
  • Lucas Memorial Collab
  • Riddles Lord
  • Veteran's Day Pokemon OU Winner
  • Sonic OC Don't STeal
  • MOTHER3 Riddles Winner X3
  • MOTHER1 Riddles 3 Wins

The only typo I noticed was when Ness said, “who do you know.” Do you mean, “how do you know” by any chance? Excuse me if I’m wrong.

I have nothing negative to say except for that typo. During the hiatus I had a look at some other fanfictions, started my own fanfiction, and after all of that I realize more and more, at how much of a skilled writer you are. In fact, it seems like you should be reviewing me and I have no right to be reviewing you. I’ll try my best though. Everyone could do with some critique, but I really couldn’t find anything to critique in this part. The action was handled nicely, the characters’ dialogue seemed very fleshed out and not one dimensional, I even like the subtle touch to Mother 1 with the bag of cheeseburgers. It wasn’t a coincidence was it?

Having Ness rely on Buzz Buzz for the first half of the fight, but having Buzz Buzz out of commission for the second half of the fight really developed Ness as a character.Throughout most of the story Ness was relying on Buzz Buzz, but this was his first true victory. I also like how the moment Frank becomes friendly to Ness, the name Frankie just seems to click right it. I wasn’t even too bothered by it during the battle sequences. I’m not even concerned by the fact that you didn’t include Frank’s robot, Frankystein Mark II in the battle. You handled that scene well enough and the inclusion of the robot may be a buzzkill on the whole scene since Frank has more potential as a fighter.

I have nothing more to say. You have impressed me with your writing style alone. I’m glad I started following this fanfic. Though your concept may be basic with the EarthBound as a novel thing, your amazing writing skill more than makes up for it.

Here we go, count zero!
Itoi Shigesato’s No. 1 Birthday Party

sprite 1up-Mushroom

Time for chapter 9!


Ness couldn’t have been happier when they met Mayor Pirkle. The Mayor’s eyes widened in disbelief as he read the note. Buzz Buzz felt triumphant, truly this was a great moment. But Pirkly had to ruin it all by giving out his trademark grin.

“Well boys,” the mayor said, “I’m sure glad you did that for me. Now, if you excuse me-”

Ness immediately got to the point.

“What about the key to the shed? You know, the key you promised to hand over?”

The mayor laughed, “Oh right, that old thing. Well, that’ll be about 500 bucks.”

“500?!” Ness shouted in disbelief.

“Yeah, didn’t you know? All rentals of the key cost exactly 500 bucks.”

Buzz Buzz then intervened, “You can’t do that!”

“I’m the mayor, bug! I can do whatever pleases me!”

Ness was about to raise his bat.

“And don’t think you can get away with that crap sonny!” Pirkle added, “Any damage you do to me will only hurt you and your family in ways you can’t even imagine! Now if you’re just stand here and whine like babies-”

Just then the phone rang. With a push of the speaker button, a gruff and familiar voice was heard.

“Hello there, Mr. Mayor.”

Pirkle almost wet his pants, “F-f-f-f-f-f-f-Frrrankie! How ya doing buddie?!”

“I’m doing well. I was calling to make sure you helped Ness with whatever he needed. You know, without trying to weasel out of your side of the deal?”

Pirkle squealed, “You-you listen here scum! I’m not intimi-intimadted by-by you! If you ever come even CLOSE to me, then I’ll-”

“You’ll what Pirkle? Call your dogs out on me? Heh, I got nothing to lose baby. You can’t threaten me. Now stop acting like a little sissy and be a man of your word!”

Pirkle quickly fumbled through his desk and threw the shed key to Ness.

“Alright, alright! You win ok? Just please don’t come and kill me!”

“Me? Kill you?” Frankie said, “I got more important things to do. Good bye you little worm.”

With that, Frankie hung up and had managed to turn the Mayor into a sniveling coward. Ness just smirked and left Town Hall.

“Well, we got the key to the shed.” Ness said, “Are we ready?”

Buzz Buzz thought it over, until he remembered something.

“Ness,” he said, “Are you aware of a thing called PSI?”

“You mean that stuff you’re always chanting?”

“Partly, let’s just say during this quest you’re going to have to learn it fast.”

“How?”

“Well, Giant’s step should be a good area to practice. Let’s go.”

With that, Ness and Buzz Buzz were off.

TLc

Always struggling for balance

  • Halloween Funfest 2013 Overall 3rd
  • ZAWA RRPS Loser
  • Writer's Badge
  • Badge Maker!
  • MOTHER2 Riddles 3+ Wins
  • Writing Bootcamp 2014
  • BFFF Participation
  • M25FF Participation Award
  • Holiday FF 13 Category 1st
  • M25FF Funky Award
  • Summers Art Collab!
  • fanvatar4
  • I believed in Smash
  • !smash collab
  • Lucas Memorial Collab
  • Riddles Lord
  • Veteran's Day Pokemon OU Winner
  • Sonic OC Don't STeal
  • MOTHER3 Riddles Winner X3
  • MOTHER1 Riddles 3 Wins

Firstly, the typo’s. I only noticed one this time round. It was at around line 5 were you spelled immediately as, “immeadiatley”. Just a minor oversight really as it didn’t detract from the story.

I don’t have anything negative to say once again. You could have handled this like the game did, but you didn’t. I’m glad you didn’t since I preferred your way of handling the scene over the way the game handled it. It seemed very much like something Pirkle would do. The scene could have been all about debating about Pirkle and the key and I would have been satisfied with the story because quality is always more important than quantity, which is how the chapters in your story are like.

That little extra scene with Buzz Buzz talking to Ness about PSI was great in setting the mood for the next scene. It made the end of the chapter seem so smooth. When the chapter ended I didn’t feel like it was abrupt at all. Despite at how this scene would be scary if it played out in real life since it was a gang leader threatening a mayor, I found it rather humorous. EarthBound is supposed to be a humorous game so this is probably one of my favorite scenes of your story so far.

I wish I could critique your writing more, but I really can’t. I don’t know how I can suggest improvements because I can’t find any way, and if I did, I would probably ruin the story. I’m doing my best to keep these reviews at a decent length, but with so little to pick on, these reviews are going to get shorter and shorter. With that said, keep up the good work!.

Here we go, count zero!
Itoi Shigesato’s No. 1 Birthday Party

sprite 1up-Mushroom

Question, after I’m done with this project, should I do an adaption of the original MOTHER as well?

TLc

Always struggling for balance

  • Halloween Funfest 2013 Overall 3rd
  • ZAWA RRPS Loser
  • Writer's Badge
  • Badge Maker!
  • MOTHER2 Riddles 3+ Wins
  • Writing Bootcamp 2014
  • BFFF Participation
  • M25FF Participation Award
  • Holiday FF 13 Category 1st
  • M25FF Funky Award
  • Summers Art Collab!
  • fanvatar4
  • I believed in Smash
  • !smash collab
  • Lucas Memorial Collab
  • Riddles Lord
  • Veteran's Day Pokemon OU Winner
  • Sonic OC Don't STeal
  • MOTHER3 Riddles Winner X3
  • MOTHER1 Riddles 3 Wins

It depends on how long you want the project to go on for. The original Mother has many non-linear paths to take, but the majority of the game is still taken up by grinding. For people like me who try to clear the game without grinding, most of the time is spent either being lost, or losing and having to retrace our steps. If you have the passion then go for it. But I wouldn’t recommend it.

Here we go, count zero!
Itoi Shigesato’s No. 1 Birthday Party

sprite 1up-Mushroom

I wonder if I should just make this a comic? I mean I know I’m already nine chapters in, so the transition would be jarring, but I have been toying with the idea.

TLc

Always struggling for balance

  • Halloween Funfest 2013 Overall 3rd
  • ZAWA RRPS Loser
  • Writer's Badge
  • Badge Maker!
  • MOTHER2 Riddles 3+ Wins
  • Writing Bootcamp 2014
  • BFFF Participation
  • M25FF Participation Award
  • Holiday FF 13 Category 1st
  • M25FF Funky Award
  • Summers Art Collab!
  • fanvatar4
  • I believed in Smash
  • !smash collab
  • Lucas Memorial Collab
  • Riddles Lord
  • Veteran's Day Pokemon OU Winner
  • Sonic OC Don't STeal
  • MOTHER3 Riddles Winner X3
  • MOTHER1 Riddles 3 Wins

If your good at drawing then by all means do it. But your writing is already fantastic.

Here we go, count zero!
Itoi Shigesato’s No. 1 Birthday Party

sprite 1up-Mushroom

Well I’m glad you think that. I just wish more people would review this. XD


After Ness unlocked the shed, he and Buzz Buzz saw the entrance to Giants Step. The odd thing was that the cave looked…sinister in a way. Like it was waiting for some gullible kid to come in and lose their life to whatever monstrosity it contained. With a gulp, Ness walked into the cave with Buzz Buzz in pursuit.

Inside was a hidden world filled with rocks, worms, and cliffs. Slugs and bugs walked together in groups, mice were devoruing bits of food they found nearby, and the snakes sleeping on rocks. It looked odd to say the least. Ness noticed a long rope at the end.

“Should we head over there?” Ness asked.

“That would be a good start, yes.”

However as they started traveling, two mice seemed to be guarding the rope. Ness sighed as he raised his bat but Buzz Buzz stopped him.

“Don’t attack them that way.”

Ness was puzzled, “Why not?”

“You need to start practicing the use of PSI. If you don’t, then you’ll easily die later on in this quest.”

“Well, how do I use this PSI?”

Buzz Buzz sighed, “It’s complicated, there are many uses of PSI. Let’s try a simple one, look at one of the mice, think of the coldest thing you know, and shout PSI Freeze Alpha!”

Ness didn’t think it would work but realized Buzz Buzz was ultimatley right in that they at least had to try. So he looked at the mouse on the left and thought of a huge bowl of ice cream sprinkled with snow. As he thought of that he shouted:

“PSI FREEZE ALPHA!”

Nothing happened.

“Think of something colder.”

Ness then thought of a huge iceberg littered with snow. He used the chant again, a small gust of wind and a few snow flakes emerged.

“Try it one more time! You’re getting there!”

Ness then thought of the earth frozen in ice, along with a million icebergs circling around it. With that, he looked at the mouse on the left and shouted “PSI FREEZE ALPHA!”

With that, a big gust of wind along with some snow landed on the mouse, freezing it perfectly. The other mouse was either too scared or stoo stupid to move.

“Alright,” Buzz Buzz said, shocked and impressed at what happened. “Let’s try another one, PSI Fire Alpha.”

“Let me guess,” Ness said, “You have to think of something hot and do the chant thing?”

“No, you have to think of something that truly angers you.”

Ness’ eyes widened.

“Really?”

“Yes, it’s not exactly a popular one to use, especially if you’re new to the process. But it’s incredibly powerful and desperate times call for desperate measures. Now Ness, you must think of the one thing that angers you most.”

Ness didn’t have to really. There was one thing that got him angry in a second, his father. Ness’ Dad was once a very rich business man who owned a successful store in Fourside. Thing is, he couldn’t be around the family unless they moved, something his wife wasn’t comfortable with.

Ness’ Dad used to write and call them all the time often bringing them checks to pay the bills and such. Then he went rogue. The store went brankrupt after he started investing his money on special drinks and special people. He then mooched off the Minch family and eventually his own family as well.

Nowadays he’s not near as successful as he used to be, and he has sympathy from no one. Ness thought about this getting angrier and angrier. He didn’t have the guts to apologize, he didn’t have any shame mooching off his family of which he barely remembered. The last time Ness saw his father was on a documentary piece where he flat out stated he didn’t even have one, none that he knew of anyway.

He didn’t even remember he had a wife and two kids, he probably didn’t care to begin with. All those checks, all those calls, they were probably just an act to make sure he had something to get out of all the holes he dug himself into.

With all of this surrounding his thoughts, Ness looked at the mouse and shouted:

“PSI FIRE ALPHA!”

The mouse went on fire in a matter of seconds. All Ness did was walk to the rope and climb it. Buzz Buzz was about to ask what he thought of but Ness interupted him by saying, “Just…don’t.”

With that, they continued onward until they encountered a strange sight. It was a gigantic Ant with a grin on its face and a few bugs behind it.

“Hello, this is one of the Your Sancturary locations…But it’s mine now…You’re going to have to take it away from me.”

Um…wow is all I can say. Wow.

sprite Sunset Violin

I tried once to follow my dreams… and ended falling off my bed.

  • Writer's Badge
  • Halloween Funfest 2013 1st Place
  • Halloween Funfest 2013 Overall 3rd
  • ZAWA RRPS Winner
  • MOTHER3 Riddles Winner X2
  • M25FF Participation Award
  • M25FF Lovely Award
  • Riddles Lord
  • GURL POWAH

There’s a small mistake I noticed on your writing:

Buzz Buzz sighed, “It’s compilcated, there are many uses of PSI.

Other than that, there’s no a lot to complain on this part. Is interesting how you gave Ness the ability to use PK Freeze and PK Fire, considering that in the game he never learn those PSI moves, and also the way he chants them, specially PK Fire by using a mad thought, in this case Ness’ father. I must say: I had never seen him the way you interpreted the character. Somehow, I can pity Ness, because is something I can relate to at acertain degree.

And talking about the fanfic in general, is very good! Your chapters are short, but they have great quality, as TLc said before. Even if there are parts changed from the original game, they are somehow fitting, and you managed to keep the esence of EarthBound there. Keep going, you are doing a great job!

Don’t lose time looking back, what is left behind can’t come back.
Don’t lose time looking at the distance, it won’t be enough to tell about your path.
Look now where are you currently stepping on, and don’t fall.

TLc

Always struggling for balance

  • Halloween Funfest 2013 Overall 3rd
  • ZAWA RRPS Loser
  • Writer's Badge
  • Badge Maker!
  • MOTHER2 Riddles 3+ Wins
  • Writing Bootcamp 2014
  • BFFF Participation
  • M25FF Participation Award
  • Holiday FF 13 Category 1st
  • M25FF Funky Award
  • Summers Art Collab!
  • fanvatar4
  • I believed in Smash
  • !smash collab
  • Lucas Memorial Collab
  • Riddles Lord
  • Veteran's Day Pokemon OU Winner
  • Sonic OC Don't STeal
  • MOTHER3 Riddles Winner X3
  • MOTHER1 Riddles 3 Wins

Good as usual. Quality over quantity, the same praise as usual. What I liked most about this part was about how you approached the PSI usage. I didn’t even realize that Ness can’t use PK Fire and PK Freeze until Sunset Violin pointed it out. It really seemed that natural. I think that thinking of cold things to generate a PK Freeze was creative enough, but you took that creativity a step further with PK Fire. It also fleshed out Ness’ back story a bit more even though you really didn’t have to go that far. I was expecting Ness to think of Porky but I think your choice seemed more effective in generating anger.

I don’t have much else to say about this individual part, but I am curious about something in the future. I’m curious at how much PSI Ness will learn. I’m okay with PK Freeze and PK Fire, but don’t give him too much PSI he doesn’t have in the game as that gets rid of the point of Paula and Poo. They have offensive PSI that Ness doesn’t have, and while they still have some use, I’m pretty sure that they will end up being downplayed. In the short run, having Ness learn PK Fire and Freeze makes it easier for you as a writer since it’s probably difficult to write about Buzz Buzz teaching Ness life-up and all the shield techniques, but in the long-run, it takes away emphasis from Paula and Poo. This problem is purely in terms of battling. I’m sure that you will do a lot with Paula and Poo in terms of character development.

Here we go, count zero!
Itoi Shigesato’s No. 1 Birthday Party

sprite 1up-Mushroom


The battle began, Buzz Buzz first used PSI Shield Sgima on Ness and himself. The Titantic just laughed as it pointed at Ness and chanted “PSI Hypnosis Beta.”

Ness instantly felt tired as he fought to stay awake.

“Buzz Buzz,” Ness said while letting out a yawn, “What’s…what’s happening?!”

“It’s trying to make you fall asleep.” Buzz Buzz then looked at the Titanic Ant, “Trying to make us immobile until the shield wears off aren’t you?”

“Trust me,” it said, “That’ll come sooner than you think.”

Just then Buzz Buzz noticed all the bugs coming together and charging at the shield. They ran at it, threw pebbles at it, they even chanted PSI Fire Alpha at it. One ant doing this was nothing to worry about but a dozen ants doing this? Buzz Buzz quickly tried to get rid of them with a dose of PSI Fire but Titanic Ant chanted “PSI Brainshock Beta” which resulted in Buzz Buzz messing up and having the move hit him instead!

However just when things were getting bad Ness rose to the plate, pointed at the bugs and chanted “PSI FREEZE ALPHA!”

Whatever few bugs that was spared ran away in fear. The Titanic Ant just scoffed as it swiped Ness with one of it arms. Ness landed at a wall and had a difficult time trying to get up. The Titanic Ant then looked at Buzz Buzz with a look that showed what it planned to do.

Ness slowly rose and began thinking of the coldest thing he ever thought, even colder than the planet being frozen. Fire may have better results but if Ness’ plan worked, then this would be faster. The Titanic Ant just laughed as it was about to chant when Ness shouted “PSI FREEZE ALPHA!”

The Titanic Ant wasn’t completely frozen but it was confused. “Wha-”

SMAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAASH!

Ness then gave a powerful swing of his bat as the Titanic Ant flew to the wall. Before it could find out what happened, Ness smashed it again, and again, and again! He was about swing another time when it shouted, “ALRIGHT!”

Ness stopped midswing. “I give up, alright?! You can have it!” The Titanic Ant then angrily disappeared to lord knows where and Ness then ran to Buzz Buzz.

“Buzz Buzz!”

The bug said one thing, “PSI lifeup.”

Just then many of Buzz Buzz’ wounds were healed as the bug began flying again.

“I see you won the battle.”

“Not exactly,” Ness said, “it forfeited before I could win.”

“Well whatever the case, we’ve now come to the first Your Sanctuary. Ness hold your hand.”

As Ness did so, a little object the size of a rock landed in his hand.

“It’s a sound stone, trust me you’ll need it.”

Buzz Buzz then pointed to an exit, “Go out there, that’s where you’ll find Giant’s Step and the first item we need, when you get there hold out the sound stone.”

As Ness exited he found he was outside and…strange enough he thought he heard music. Shrugging it off he went towards the giant footprint and held out the stone. Just then, a huge brightness engulfed him as a short yet soothing melody filled his ears.

Just then Ness thought he saw someone, a baby with a red cap on his head. As the brightness dimmed Ness looked outward and saw the entire town of Onett.

He sure was gonna miss it.

TLc

Always struggling for balance

  • Halloween Funfest 2013 Overall 3rd
  • ZAWA RRPS Loser
  • Writer's Badge
  • Badge Maker!
  • MOTHER2 Riddles 3+ Wins
  • Writing Bootcamp 2014
  • BFFF Participation
  • M25FF Participation Award
  • Holiday FF 13 Category 1st
  • M25FF Funky Award
  • Summers Art Collab!
  • fanvatar4
  • I believed in Smash
  • !smash collab
  • Lucas Memorial Collab
  • Riddles Lord
  • Veteran's Day Pokemon OU Winner
  • Sonic OC Don't STeal
  • MOTHER3 Riddles Winner X3
  • MOTHER1 Riddles 3 Wins

It takes a skilled writer to write action scenes like that. You nailed the action scene down. It’s good that you deviated from how the battle would have played out if it were in the game. If it was like the game, then it would just be Ness using PK Rockin’, then bashing and healing for the rest of the fight, this method was much better. I’m also starting to notice how Buzz Buzz is becoming more and more weaker, while Ness is becoming more and more stronger. Interesting, so by the point Buzz Buzz dies, assuming he dies, Ness will be powerful enough to take care of himself, and eventually he will be powerful enough to take care of Paula, then Jeff, and even Poo. I’ll be looking forward to how Ness develops.

As for Ness entering the sanctuary, I didn’t really feel anything creative coming from it. Sure, Buzz Buzz gave Ness the sound stone, but that was the only really interesting thing that happened. Reaching each of his sanctuaries is supposed to give some sort of feeling to Ness. I know that you want to stick to the game, but the sanctuaries may be the best times to add sentimental value to Ness’ journey. Maybe have a whole flashback scene appear whenever Ness reaches a sanctuary, not just Ness seeing a flash from his past. Don’t take this critique too harshly, as it’s just a nitpick about a missed opportunity, the overall story is still fantastic.

Here we go, count zero!
Itoi Shigesato’s No. 1 Birthday Party

sprite 1up-Mushroom


On the way back to Onett Ness had a boat load of questions in his mind. What was with the music? What was with the image of the baby? He guessed the baby was him but what was the purpose? Also, was it him or was Buzz Buzz getting weaker? Sure he still threw quite a punch but he’s been getting maimed more and more lately. Maybe he was always like this and guys like the sharks and that Starman thing were just weaker than him.

Whatever the reason, Ness realized that it was probably for the best to keep these thoughts to himself. But then as if he read his mind Buzz Buzz asked Ness a question.

“Do you know why you heard that melody?”

Ness looked at Buzz Buzz and said, “No, not really.”

“It’s but one of an eight part melody that we must form together. The next one is at Twoson, which if my memory is correct should be at the end of Onett.”

Ness’ eyes widened at the thought of seven more melodies to collect. Just then as the duo were walking down the Onett streets Ness saw Porky surrounding a few younger kids.

“And that’s how I saved my little brother and my rather slow minded friend.” Porky said with a very arrogant tone in his voice.

Ness however smirked as Buzz Buzz and him approached Porky with Ness holding his bat on his shoulder.

“Hello there Porky.” Ness said knowing full well that Porky would panic.

And as Porky realized who greeted him he turned white and grew a painfully faux smile.

“NESS…BUDDY! HA HA HA!” Porky said, his eyes filled with panic, “Um, what are you doing here?”

“Oh nothing much,” Ness said with a cocky grin, “Me and Buzz Buzz are just going on another adventure. Would you like to come with us?”

“A-A-Another adventure?” Porky said,

Buzz Buzz immediately got in on the act, “Oh yes! Filled with danger, monsters, and all the stuff you could obviously beat in a milisecond.”

Porky stammered, “Um, uh, ummmm, l-look here guys adventure here is not my thing, sorry-”

One of the little kids then said, “But you said you wouldn’t reject adventure for your life!”

Porky almost fainted, realizing all of his lies coming back to bite him hard. So instead Porky just broke down and left. After saying goodbye to the kids Ness and Buzz Buzz then walked to the road which lead to Twoson. Thing is however it was blocked by four cops, one of them being the famous Chief Strong and the others being rookies.

“Sorry kid,” one of the rookies said, “Only adults can come through.”

“Why?” Ness asked,

“There’s been an infestation of walking mushrooms lately.” Another rookie said, “Children can’t handle the infection those things have. Looks like you’ll have-”

“Wait a minute.” It was Chief Strong who said that, “I know you. Yeah, you’re the kid who beat up Frankie and forced him to disband the Sharks.”

Ness was surprised, “I thought only the mayor knew that-”

“Hah!” Strong said, “You think someone like Frankie’s gonna let Pirkle take the credit? No, Frankie hates him too much…Listen if you’re tough enough take on the leader of the sharks, I’m pretty sure you can take on whatever’s on that road.”

Ness was flattered by the Chief’s confidence, “Thank you.”

“Don’t mention it kid. Now if you gents excuse me,” the Chief pulled out a gameboy, “I’m gonna play me some Kirby’s Dream Land.”

With that, Ness and Buzz Buzz headed to Twoson.

TLc

Always struggling for balance

  • Halloween Funfest 2013 Overall 3rd
  • ZAWA RRPS Loser
  • Writer's Badge
  • Badge Maker!
  • MOTHER2 Riddles 3+ Wins
  • Writing Bootcamp 2014
  • BFFF Participation
  • M25FF Participation Award
  • Holiday FF 13 Category 1st
  • M25FF Funky Award
  • Summers Art Collab!
  • fanvatar4
  • I believed in Smash
  • !smash collab
  • Lucas Memorial Collab
  • Riddles Lord
  • Veteran's Day Pokemon OU Winner
  • Sonic OC Don't STeal
  • MOTHER3 Riddles Winner X3
  • MOTHER1 Riddles 3 Wins

Somehow, I got the feeling that you just wanted to get to Twoson. The overall pace of this chapter seemed faster than the others. I know I have no right to talk about pacing, but that’s just what I felt. I actually think that it was a good idea to move things along after Ness had collected the melody. The event in which Ness fights the cops works from a gameplay perspective, but in a story perspective, it wouldn’t make sense and it would get stale. How would Ness be able to heal his wounds using hamburgers? You handled that part of the story better than the game, because it would be logical that the cops would let Ness through since he has already proved to be strong enough to take on the sharks. The game doesn’t even explain why the road was blocked off.

That little event with Pokey was a nice touch on your part. Even though it wasn’t anything that happened in-game, it still seemed very much like something which could. It was very much in Pokey’s character to take all the credit. I don’t have much else to say about this scene. It was a very good extra scene to add in to develop Pokey and Ness.

Here we go, count zero!
Itoi Shigesato’s No. 1 Birthday Party

sprite 1up-Mushroom


The Police weren’t lying when they said the road was filled with walking mushrooms. Every other minute Ness and Buzz Buzz would have an encounter with one of those abominations of nature. The duo even came across a man who was controlled by a mushroom on his head, this was Ness’ first indication that something strange was happening here.

When they arrived in Twoson, Ness was surprised at how much it was like Onett. There was a department store, a hospital, a library, it was as if Ness hadn’t left at all. There were more than few differences though. For starters, Twoson was the home of Burglin Park, a notorious flea market filled with shady deals. Twoson also had the Chaos Theater, which would often be very chaotic if someone had more than a few drinks.

As Ness and Buzz Buzz walked further into Towson, Ness came across…this sight. It was near Burglin Park, there were four people overall. Two of them were girls, the kind you saw in cartoon shows, the annoying brats. One of them was a particularly round and slobbish boy with a rather shoddy display table filled with various gadgets and useless trinkets. The final person was a neatly dressed boy with an impressive display of mini-rockets, watches, and other things.

As Ness approached them he started noticing other things, like how the girls would laugh at the round boy, or how the neat boy would look at fat one and chuckle nastily. When Ness approached the scene, the round kid immeadialtey waddled to Ness as a quiet “This’ll be rich.” insult was released from the neat kid’s mouth.

“Hello Mister.” The round kid said, “I’d um, like to show you some new products I made. They’ll really change mankind.”

“Umm, ok?” Ness said, “What’s your name?”

“Uh, A-Apple Kid,” he stuttered, “at least that’s what I’m called by many people.”

“Because you’re fat.” The neat kid said nonchalantly while the girls giggled.

Apple Kid groaned and turned to the neat looking one, “Orange Kid please don’t ruin this for me!”

The Orange Kid laughed at that and proceeded to pick up everything he deemed worthless.

“Oh trust me,” Orange Kid said, “you don’t need my help ruining your reputation.”

Ness wanted to prove Orange Kid wrong but, the Orange Kid was right. All of the stuff on Apple’s Kid’s table were either the poor man’s version of a popular product, or something that didn’t even resemble a normal object. Ness just nervously chuckled and said:

“Look Apple Kid…Um all of this stuff is nice and all.”

The Apple Kid then became desperate, “I’ll take anything! A quarter, a dollar, I don’t even need money! I’ll settle for a cheeseburger! Just something that’ll prove someone will buy my creations!”

The Orange Kid just laughed as he pushed the table over, knocking all of Apple Kid’s inventions to the ground.

“You don’t get do you?!” Orange Kid said, “You can’t just make some gadgets and call it an invention. It takes more than that, moron. Now why don’t you go back crying to your little rat and think about what it takes to make a real inventor.”

And if this couldn’t get any worse, Orange Kid then stomped all over Apple Kid’s products and even threw some of them in the trash. As the Orange Kid and the girls continued laughing and giggling, Apple Kid just looked at all the mess that was his work and sighed sadly. The thing that made it hard to watch was Apple Kid’s reaction. There were no tears on his face not even one, just a sad expression of utter defeat.

However as Apple Kid just sat on the grass with no hope in his eyes at all, Ness approached Apple Kid and pulled out a cheeseburger and handed it to him. The Apple Kid smiled as he took the cheeseburger and began eating it. Ness then sat down next to Apple Kid and started eating a cheeseburger as well.

“Where’d you get these?” Apple Kid asked.

Ness chuckled, “A crazy arcade manager.”

After that exchange, they just ate their food while looking at the sky. When the meal was fully consumed, Ness and Apple Kid both stood up and shook each other’s hands. Apple Kid’s eyes then widened, “Oh, I almost forgot” he said as he pulled out a metallic eraser from one of his pockets.

“This is a pencil eraser. It erases anything that looks like a pencil, you might need it.”

Ness smiled and gave Apple Kid a thank you while putting the eraser in his bag. As Ness walked away he heard Buzz Buzz voice once more.

“That was a very noble thing you did Ness.”

Ness then jolted in surprise, “Oh, I didn’t know you were there Buzz Buzz.” Ness said , “Well, what are we here?”

“Before we look for the next melody,” Buzz Buzz explained, “We must look for a girl named Paula.”

Paula, Ness heard of her before. She was that girl who was able to do a lot of psychic powers at a very young age. She, along with her parents, claimed her gift came from Jesus himself though there were detractors. As Ness was reminiscing all of the stuff about her he heard long ago, Buzz Buzz continued onward.

“We must find her immediately, she’ll be of a great help. If only I knew where her house was.”

Just then Ness happened to find a discarded newspaper.

“Uh, Buzz Buzz,” Ness said, “I don’t think Paula’s at home.”

Buzz Buzz then looked at the paper to understand what Ness was talking about. There, in big bold letters was the headline: “PAULA KIDNAPPED! EVERYONE’S BAFFLED!”

TLc

Always struggling for balance

  • Halloween Funfest 2013 Overall 3rd
  • ZAWA RRPS Loser
  • Writer's Badge
  • Badge Maker!
  • MOTHER2 Riddles 3+ Wins
  • Writing Bootcamp 2014
  • BFFF Participation
  • M25FF Participation Award
  • Holiday FF 13 Category 1st
  • M25FF Funky Award
  • Summers Art Collab!
  • fanvatar4
  • I believed in Smash
  • !smash collab
  • Lucas Memorial Collab
  • Riddles Lord
  • Veteran's Day Pokemon OU Winner
  • Sonic OC Don't STeal
  • MOTHER3 Riddles Winner X3
  • MOTHER1 Riddles 3 Wins

This chapter brought up a few interesting points. Firstly, are apple kid and orange kid their real names. In the context of EarthBound I didn’t give it two thoughts but in the context of a story, it’s really thought provoking. The other thing which came to my mind was how Apple Kid is like a foil character to Porky. In fact, Apple kid and Orange kid are like foils to Ness and Porky. Your description of apple kid kinda sounded like Porky at the beginning so maybe that is what provoked the thought. Turning orange kid into a jerk was a good move on your part as is further cements the foil. Just think about it, fat nice kid with a skinny jerk as opposed to a fat jerk with a skinny nice kid.

About Buzz Buzz being written out of most of the story, I think that this was good on your part as I’m pretty sure that Buzz Buzz is going to die soon and apple kid is going to be a major recurring character now. So it’s probably to better to just focus on the bond between apple kid and Ness without Buzz Buzz getting in the way. I have nothing more to say. Reviewing your story is teaching me a lot about writing. I think I’ll continue on as it’s a great learning experience for me.

Here we go, count zero!
Itoi Shigesato’s No. 1 Birthday Party

sprite 1up-Mushroom

Well to celebrate my 16th birthday let’s read ANOTHER chapter in this unfolding epic.


As the duo walked around Twoson, they saw that Paula wasn’t the only one who was kidnapped. Teachers, husbands, couples, cows, it seemed everyone was at risk. Ness and Buzz Buzz however had finally given up when Paula’s own parents had no clue whatsoever what happened to Paula. Her Mother was convinced that Jesus was with her so she shouldn’t have to worry, while her Dad didn’t even know she was missing.

The duo were now at Burglin Park. Ness was looking at all the junk no one wanted while Buzz Buzz searched for clues. Just then, as Ness was approaching a rather shady looking house, a big man with a black mustache jumped off the roof and surrounded Ness.

“Hey kid, how come you wanna snoop in my house?!” the man asked as his mustache rustled.

“Who-who are you?” Ness asked.

“Name’s Everdred.” He said, “I’m a pretty famous guy,”-he added a cruel grin to his face-“For all the wrong reasons.”

At first, it seemed that Ness was in deep trouble, he doubted that even PSI would be able to take this man down. But then, Everdred’s eyes widened.

“Wait a minute,” he said, “Maybe if…”

He paused for a minute and then said, “You wanna make a couple bucks?”

Ness was skeptical but also interested. Everdred explained, “I lost the key to my cabin months ago, I’d search for it myself but I’m particularly busy at the moment and I need a delivery man.”

Ness was about to ask how much but then Buzz Buzz cut in.

“We’ll do nothing of the sort!” He said fiercely.

“Hold on Buzz Buzz,” Ness said, “We don’t know what he’s offering! It could be worth it.”

“This man is dangerous, I’ve heard all about him.” Buzz Buzz said, “He’ll try to swindle us the moment he gets the chance!”

“I’ll give you a millions bucks” Everdred said flatly.

Ness quickly said “DEAL!”

“NESS!”

“Good kid,” Everdred said, “Now my cabin is on the far east of Peaceful Rest Valley. It’s a safe bet that’s where my key is. If you give it back to me, I’ll give you the reward.”

And with that, Everdred walked into his house. As the duo walked to Peaceful Rest Valley, Buzz Buzz said something about greed being evil but Ness didn’t hear him over the thoughts of all that money being in his hands.

TLc

Always struggling for balance

  • Halloween Funfest 2013 Overall 3rd
  • ZAWA RRPS Loser
  • Writer's Badge
  • Badge Maker!
  • MOTHER2 Riddles 3+ Wins
  • Writing Bootcamp 2014
  • BFFF Participation
  • M25FF Participation Award
  • Holiday FF 13 Category 1st
  • M25FF Funky Award
  • Summers Art Collab!
  • fanvatar4
  • I believed in Smash
  • !smash collab
  • Lucas Memorial Collab
  • Riddles Lord
  • Veteran's Day Pokemon OU Winner
  • Sonic OC Don't STeal
  • MOTHER3 Riddles Winner X3
  • MOTHER1 Riddles 3 Wins

I think that it was a good choice to have this chapter focus more on Everdred than the Polestar preschool. That one line summed it up better than any banter could have done so. When I read that Paula’s Dad didn’t even know she was missing, I thought that it was such a likely thing to do. In other words, it was in character. I think it was like that in the game as well, but I don’t care; you still handled that well.

As for the meat of the story, the Everdred encounter, it was a good choice to not make Everdred and Ness fight. In the context of the game, people wouldn’t really question it much but in the context of the story, it just makes Everdred seem reckless. Everdred is some guy which is friendly with Ness, but like Frank, he really isn’t the sort of person Ness should be friendly with. Painting him as more of a swindler seemed to add some depth to his character as in the games, we don’t really know much about him. I’m sure you know that the wad of bills Ness receives from Everdred is 10,000 bucks and not one million bucks, but I think that it was a good choice to have him offer a million bucks as opposed to 10,000 bucks as it seems much more likely for a swindler to offer a million bucks. Even the subtle detail of having Everdred saying it flatly made it so… Mother-esque! Whether the wad of bills Ness later receives is a million bucks or 10,000 bucks doesn’t matter too much, but if it were a million bucks that Ness receives, then it would make the story much more consistent though I doubt that Ness would use the million dollars to free the runaway five.

Here we go, count zero!
Itoi Shigesato’s No. 1 Birthday Party

sprite 1up-Mushroom

You know I wonder. Instead of a boring amount of text, how bout I do an animated series?

I have the people, resources, and I have the equipment.

;)

TLc

Always struggling for balance

  • Halloween Funfest 2013 Overall 3rd
  • ZAWA RRPS Loser
  • Writer's Badge
  • Badge Maker!
  • MOTHER2 Riddles 3+ Wins
  • Writing Bootcamp 2014
  • BFFF Participation
  • M25FF Participation Award
  • Holiday FF 13 Category 1st
  • M25FF Funky Award
  • Summers Art Collab!
  • fanvatar4
  • I believed in Smash
  • !smash collab
  • Lucas Memorial Collab
  • Riddles Lord
  • Veteran's Day Pokemon OU Winner
  • Sonic OC Don't STeal
  • MOTHER3 Riddles Winner X3
  • MOTHER1 Riddles 3 Wins

Funnily enough I was thinking that as well for your story. But your text is not boring. There was an animated series called EarthBound animated which hasn’t been updated in years, so this would act as a spiritual successor to that.

I have no problem as long as you have the dedication for it.

Here we go, count zero!
Itoi Shigesato’s No. 1 Birthday Party

sprite 1up-Mushroom

I meant boring as in just plain text, I’m pretty sure by now that people don’t think my text is boring. Funnily enough, my intention from the get go was to make this an actual cartoon series but at that time I had neither the equipment nor the people to pull it off. So for a while this was how the story existed. Now though, I think I can do it. I might continue this until it’s done though or in case the series plan doesn’t succeed.

sprite 1up-Mushroom


Well everyone knows the old saying of “Don’t trust a book by its cover”. Just change book by its cover with area by its title and you have Peaceful Rest Valley in a nutshell. If only Ness had asked Everdred what Peaceful Rest Valley was like. He probably would’ve said no to the deal if he knew. Peaceful Rest Valley was a huge nightmare! Not only was it larger than Onet and Twoson combined, it was also most certainly NOT peaceful!

Ness and Buzz Buzz realized this right away as they came across a giant tree with a face. At first Ness said:

“Well, maybe the tree is friendly.”

And then the tree blew up in their faces, literally. The duo fell to the ground as Buzz Buzz quickly chanted PSI lifeup Beta. Once they were healed enough to walk, Ness quickly gripped his bat and was prepared for any more surprises. They kept walking upwards until they noticed walking plants.

“Buzz Buzz ,” Ness said, “why is everything suddenly coming alive?”

“Must be a negative force in the air,” Buzz Buzz said, “you’d be surprised what other things can become sentient if they’re given enough power.”

“Oh,” Ness said obviously even more confused, “Good to know.”

As they walked further the duo noticed a strange man in a complete black suit with a top hat. He was taking pictures of everything he could find. When he noticed Ness, the man said:

“Ah, hello there. Would you like to have your picture taken?”

“Um, no sir.” Ness said, “I just wanted to know if there’s a cabin near here.”

The man shook his head but his eyes told Ness that he knew more than what he’s leading on, “Can’t say I have. Not around these parts of the valley anyway. Do you sleep much young boy?”

Buzz Buzz said, “Um, I think we should leave Ness.”

“Not yet,” the man said, "Just answer my question young one. "

“Um…yes?” Ness said, obviously creeped out.

The man smiled, “Well, just pay attention to your dreams from now on. You may find a clue to solve your problem. Also, if you go left from here, you’ll find a village. Maybe someone can help you better than I did.”

With that, the man left the duo to do whatever he pleased. Buzz Buzz wanted to move on but Ness decided to rest.

“Maybe the man’s right, you never know.” Ness said, and with great reluctance, Buzz Buzz agreed.

Ness then sat on the ground and closed his eyes. At first there was nothing but darkness and then the voice of a young girl appeared.

“Help me Ness,” the voice begged, “My name is Paula. Please help me!”

“Paula?” Ness said, “Where are you?”

“I’m not sure,” the voice replied, “I think I’m in a cabin in Peaceful Rest Valley. I can hear water outside, please help me! I’m scared.”

“Hold on!” Ness said, “I’ll come for you. Please wait for me! Please!”

And then Ness was awakened by Buzz Buzz.

“Calm down Ness!” Buzz Buzz said, “What happened?!”

“I…I heard Paula calling for me.” Ness said.

Buzz Buzz nodded, “It seems she’s able to telepathically communicate with you. What did she say?”

“She said was somewhere in peaceful rest valley,” Ness said slowly realizing, “in a cabin.”

Buzz Buzz understood, “The same cabin we were asked to investigate.”

TLc

Always struggling for balance

  • Halloween Funfest 2013 Overall 3rd
  • ZAWA RRPS Loser
  • Writer's Badge
  • Badge Maker!
  • MOTHER2 Riddles 3+ Wins
  • Writing Bootcamp 2014
  • BFFF Participation
  • M25FF Participation Award
  • Holiday FF 13 Category 1st
  • M25FF Funky Award
  • Summers Art Collab!
  • fanvatar4
  • I believed in Smash
  • !smash collab
  • Lucas Memorial Collab
  • Riddles Lord
  • Veteran's Day Pokemon OU Winner
  • Sonic OC Don't STeal
  • MOTHER3 Riddles Winner X3
  • MOTHER1 Riddles 3 Wins

I never actually considered the irony of the area name of Peaceful Rest Valley, it was good that you brought it up. I think it was a good thing to have not included the photo-man in the story up until now because despite the fact that he is a memorable part of EarthBound, I think he’s more infamous than famous. I mean when you go to Dalaam, he takes your picture when your outside the palace, and then takes your picture again a few seconds later inside the palace. Your rendition of him is much better than the games rendition of him. He still retains some of that creepy “who are you” atmosphere, but he’s not as annoying as in the game.

As for Paula contacting Ness, I was wondering how you were going to handle that. You haven’t written about the hotels yet have you? That’s fine as in writing, does the author mention every single time a character goes to sleep or visits a hotel? I think you provided a nice substitute.

Overall there isn’t much I can say about this part as nothing much really happened in it. I don’t blame you for that as story-wise nothing much happens in peaceful rest valley, and you would be stuck with even less of a story if you had killed off Buzz Buzz.

Here we go, count zero!
Itoi Shigesato’s No. 1 Birthday Party

sprite 1up-Mushroom

Wel I submitted the first bulk of it on the Starmen.NET fanfics page. Maybe it’ll get noticed more.

EDIT: If in case that doesn’t work, I’ll just post it on my deviantART account. Which is here: http://1up-mushroom.deviantart.com

TLc

Always struggling for balance

  • Halloween Funfest 2013 Overall 3rd
  • ZAWA RRPS Loser
  • Writer's Badge
  • Badge Maker!
  • MOTHER2 Riddles 3+ Wins
  • Writing Bootcamp 2014
  • BFFF Participation
  • M25FF Participation Award
  • Holiday FF 13 Category 1st
  • M25FF Funky Award
  • Summers Art Collab!
  • fanvatar4
  • I believed in Smash
  • !smash collab
  • Lucas Memorial Collab
  • Riddles Lord
  • Veteran's Day Pokemon OU Winner
  • Sonic OC Don't STeal
  • MOTHER3 Riddles Winner X3
  • MOTHER1 Riddles 3 Wins

I think your fanfic is getting noticed enough here. Even though it’s mainly me and you commenting on this, if you look at the views, then it’s clear that others are following this. It’s just that there isn’t so much to comment on your story, that’s it.

As for the lack of reviews, there is a reason that a badge is given out for people who do lot’s of fanfic reviews, there aren’t many fanfic reviews going on in the writing forum to begin with. Most fanfic topics are just the writer updating their fanfiction with hardly anyone else commenting. I consider myself lucky that I get so many comments on my fanfic so don’t get think that you’re not getting much attention.

Here we go, count zero!
Itoi Shigesato’s No. 1 Birthday Party

sprite 1up-Mushroom

Sorry, I tend to be a bit egotistic at times, it’s sort of a flaw I’m trying to get over.

sprite 1up-Mushroom


As Ness and Buzz Buzz headed left to the village, Buzz Buzz was even angrier.

“We just agreed to bring the cabin key to Paula’s kidnapper.” He said, “Greed never pays.”

“Now hold on.” Ness said, “We don’t know for sure that Everdred’s the culprit, if anything the kidnapper could have stolen the key and used the cabin.”

Yet, even as they entered the bizarre Happy Happy Village, Ness still couldn’t stop thinking about it. However that all changed when the duo actually paid attention to their surroundings. For starters, everyone wore this huge unsettling smile on their faces. Everyone from the adults to the toddlers had a very plastic smile slapped on their faces. Secondly, everything was covered in blue! Blue houses, blue cars, blue cows, everything that wasn’t human was blue!

Ness first asked a middle aged blonde woman about the huge color of blue everywhere. He didn’t get a straight answer:

“Why hello there young man!” The woman said, “Are you here to learn about the true religion of Happy Happism?”

Ness and Buzz Buzz looked at each other and Ness then said, “Happy Happism?”

“Oh yes!” The woman sounded extra giddy as if she were faking it, “Happy Happism is the one and only true way to become solely happy.”

Ness still didn’t get it, the woman grew slightly annoyed.

“A long time ago, Carpainter, the prophet listened to a message from the Lord almighty himself and wrote it all down, resulting in the Happiest of all religions!”

Ness then lied, “Oh! Yes, I remember now! Good ole’ Happy Happism, yeah. Um, do you have any idea where we could find a young girl named Paula?”

The woman’s eyes twinkled, “You mean the chosen one?”

“Uh…”

“The one Carpaitner himself selected to be his apprentice in spreading the truth? Oh yes, I’ve heard many things about Paula.”

Ness was officially creeped out by this. “Well um, we gotta go and uh talk to Carpainter about becoming members.”

“Oh!” The woman said and pointed to a huge blue church in the middle of the town, “He’s over there. You know, you’re not the only one who seeks an audience.”

“Really?” Ness said, slowly moving away.

“Yes, why just a moment ago a round blonde haired kid asked for Carpainter.”

Ness stopped in his tracks. Round? Blonde haired? Could she talking about…no no it had to be someone else. Ness and Buzz Buzz then walked into the Blue Church, ready to find Carpainter.

TLc

Always struggling for balance

  • Halloween Funfest 2013 Overall 3rd
  • ZAWA RRPS Loser
  • Writer's Badge
  • Badge Maker!
  • MOTHER2 Riddles 3+ Wins
  • Writing Bootcamp 2014
  • BFFF Participation
  • M25FF Participation Award
  • Holiday FF 13 Category 1st
  • M25FF Funky Award
  • Summers Art Collab!
  • fanvatar4
  • I believed in Smash
  • !smash collab
  • Lucas Memorial Collab
  • Riddles Lord
  • Veteran's Day Pokemon OU Winner
  • Sonic OC Don't STeal
  • MOTHER3 Riddles Winner X3
  • MOTHER1 Riddles 3 Wins

To be honest, I think that the newer chapters are becoming less and less interesting. Their still good, but there just doesn’t seem to be much of a twist to the story established in the game. You have some small to medium twists here and there, but nothing huge like when you allowed Buzz Buzz to live in the earlier chapters. With this specific chapter, the only twist was that you had one person explain everything to Ness and Buzz Buzz instead of many people giving small bits of information to Ness. Having Everdread send Ness on a mission was a good enough twist, so have more twists like that. Maybe have Paula and Ness dislike each other, that would definitely be a great twist.

Each chapter is too short. I’ve been avoiding to say this because I believe in quality over quantity, but the recent chapters have been so short that there isn’t much time for you as a writer to add something memorable to it. The first few chapters were at a decent length so I recommend looking at those to determine the lengths of future episodes. By all means keep going, but I would like to see some new twists to the story.

Here we go, count zero!
Itoi Shigesato’s No. 1 Birthday Party

sprite 1up-Mushroom

Sorry I haven’t been updating in a while guys. School pretty much happened. Hopefully I’ll be able to update more.

Funnily enough TheLoneChallenger actually made a partly accurate prediction in his latest review. Paula will actually come to hate a member of the chosen four. Not saying who it is as to keep some interest in this adaption but feel free to guess who it is.

sprite 1up-Mushroom

Well, my original BETA reader hasn’t responded in a while, can anyone else BETA read for a while?

sprite 1up-Mushroom

Time for a sneak preview:


Ness was surprised to say the least.

“Did I just hear you say-”

“These are tough times Ness, we all have to make compromises in order to succeed.”

As the minutes passed by, he didn’t know what to do. It sounded legit, but that’s the problem. It sounded too legit, like there was a sort of catch.

“What’s your answer?”

Ness tried to make a decision but he just couldn’t…until a thought entered his mind.

“Yeah, I’ll agree if you’ll explain one thing.”

Hopefully this whole chapter’ll be worth the long hiatus the fic endured.