I agree; this doesn't sound like such a horrible idea. I can't remember how many times I've become lost trying to find info regarding a certain control code or parameters for collision data. I know everyone and their dog has a wiki these days, but using one for the purpose of compiling community-based programming information strikes me as pretty convenient. Datacrystal aside, I believe we could use one.
It doesn't really matter whether we get our own wiki or we use an existing one. (Heck, I made my own ROM hacking wiki that never went anywhere that we could use.) What matters is that we all use one somewhere -- "all" being the key word. It wouldn't do much good to put up all the info if nobody else here knows it's there. So I think we should coordinate our efforts on it, and make sure that the info will actually be used.
I do not seem to have been clear enough. Data Crystal was started by a few of the PK Hack moderators as a wiki for PK Hack. It covers all games because (1) a few PK Hackers had been looking into hacking other games and (2) there appeared to be a niche to fill in the greater ROM Hacking community.
Please do not splinter the information by creating an extraneous EarthBound-only wiki.
It's OK, the other guys in #pkhax already basically told me not to. I've already moved my info to the Data Crystal wiki and deleted my own.
But the Data Crystal wiki isn't going to be useful if it isn't actually used. Where was the info on the control codes? The flag crusade? The standard arguments list? The formulae for battles and for leveling up? Why aren't we putting everything we know on it? EarthBound's page there was created in 2005; that stuff should have been on there ages ago by now. I've put some of it up now, of course, and I'll continue to put up whatever I find, but I really don't want to be the only guy using this.
In particular, we need to sticky this thread (or make another one and sticky that) to publicize the wiki, and we should also link to it from here. Once I get the control codes page polished up a bit I'm going to link to it from the control codes thread, for example, because BlueAntoid's version is becoming obsolete (if it hasn't been already).
Earlier today I was in #pkhax asking about the music format. Not one, but two people basically told me, "Well, I used to know stuff about that, but now I don't anymore". This is exactly the sort of thing that the wiki is supposed to prevent! So let's get this party started, guys...
- Kef
The rule of thumb of projects (at least internet projects) is if no one else is doing it, do it yourself. Update the wiki to be up to your standards if it's not up to your standards right now.
I already am. My point is that this should be a good resource by and for everyone, rather than just by and for myself. A wiki is useless if it isn't actually used, and I was just pointing to the wiki in its current state (well, its state as of yesterday) as a prime example.
Moreover, I think we should all fully commit to it. No more personal notes, no more text docs scattered over the web. Further EB ROM hacking info should begin and end there.
- Kef
Do people still work on figuring out the ROM though? I don't hang out in the chan, but I almost never see new discoveries posted about (or the section updated). Seems like most activity these days is non-experts trying to make hacks.
Well, I've made three minor discoveries about the control codes in the past couple of days (one of which turned out to already be in the thread, but not in the text files). And I think there's still work being done with figuring out how the battle backgrounds work. And surely if nobody else is working on anything else right now, they will in the future.
I'm going to go ahead and try to pull together a lot of the old IPS patches that were made, and organize them in Data Crystal. I know we had a lot of crazy-useful ones at one point, including one that bypassed the naming screen and another that created a "save anytime function." It would be really useful to get those all in one place.
If anyone has any, toss them my way.
So... how come we don't have a sticky topic about the wiki yet?
A link at the top of the forum like there is to the PK Hack website (or on the PK Hack website) to the wiki would make sense. I actually do not know who can change that message...
I thhink we SHOULD have a wiki, because it would attract more fans to PK Hack and bring in more downloads. :d
AngryBound – Earth is angry and wants people who downvote my posts dead
Our wiki should be called something like Wikibound, or PK Wiki.
AngryBound – Earth is angry and wants people who downvote my posts dead
Well, you may go to the PK Hack site.
http://pkhack.fobby.net/start.php
Dunno if this would help you, but good luck anyway. 
livan is not a fakeposter. He’s just a friendly but shy guy who does not speak English well, enjoys off-topic and simple discussions, uses excesive ellipses and n_n smilies, and apologizes constantly. That’s all. And he’s not Wootman. Seriously.